Reply
AllenM
Posts: 10,206
Topics: 221
Kudos: 2,143
Solutions: 377
Registered: ‎12-14-2008

Re: Symantec Please Speak Up About Rash of Trojans

Hi Tosh,

 

I do understand where you are coming from and I am truly sorry for the trouble you are having with this.

 

Dick mentioned some very good (and free) malware removal sites in the following post:

 

http://community.norton.com/t5/Norton-Internet-Security-Norton/Symantec-Please-Speak-Up-About-Rash-o...

 

I would suggest that you open a ticket with one of them.

 

Best of wishes.

Allen

Windows 7 Ultimate SP 1, 32 bit, 4 GB * NIS 2012 (19.8.0.14) * Ghost 15 * IE 9, Firefox, Safari.
Test laptop with W7 Home Premium 64 bit * NIS 2012 (19.8.0.14)
Newbie
techvisitor
Posts: 1
Registered: ‎08-23-2012

Re: Symantec Please Speak Up About Rash of Trojans

car825 wrote:

dickevans wrote:

Hi,

Just a couple of comments. If the malware and virus developers wanted honest jobs I'm sure they would apply

Reinstalling from the installation disk is not 100%. Some things have been known to slip past and remain to bite again

Stay well and surf safe


What malware can survive a reinstall from a system image?  What about the malware giving people on the forum so much trouble now? 


Does anyone know the answer to this?  My system is clean, but I like knowing I can fix things with a full image copy restore.  How confident should I be in percentage terms that this is true.

 

 

I am mobile computer tech and have visited several customers with these infections.  I have in fact performed factory recovery on systems and had the virus maintain itself on the hard disk. A fully cleaned system was reinfected on reboot.  

 

I determined that the hard drive had to be nuked. We performed a full bit-by-bit erasure of all partition tables, boot sectors, and did a clean 1pass wipe.   

 

Having done that.... the computer was clean after a second re-install.  The downside is that we lost the manufacturers recovery partition and the supporting software and hardware the computer came with.  Thank MS for OEM COA labels on the side of machines! :)

 

Bot Obliterator
Quads
Posts: 13,245
Registered: ‎07-21-2008

Re: Symantec Please Speak Up About Rash of Trojans


techvisitor wrote:

 

I am mobile computer tech and have visited several customers with these infections.  I have in fact performed factory recovery on systems and had the virus maintain itself on the hard disk. A fully cleaned system was reinfected on reboot.  

 

I determined that the hard drive had to be nuked. We performed a full bit-by-bit erasure of all partition tables, boot sectors, and did a clean 1pass wipe.   

 

Having done that.... the computer was clean after a second re-install.  The downside is that we lost the manufacturers recovery partition and the supporting software and hardware the computer came with.  Thank MS for OEM COA labels on the side of machines! :)

 

 


I am mobile computer tech and have visited several customers with these infections.  I have in fact performed factory recovery on systems and had the virus maintain itself on the hard disk. A fully cleaned system was reinfected on reboot.  

 

As I have been saying for certian malware families for awhile

I have had Systems in front of me, but I never had to or attempted a reformat or factory reset on a users machine,  I go about removing the infection while not touching a persons personal data or good programs, so what is the point of me doing a factory reset or reformat etc. When I know what I am doing in removing infections??

 

Also as a Computer tech, please don't call a piece of malware a Virus when it is not,  this thread is talking about the trojans detected that are actually the zeroacces rootkit,  It keeps changing so that is so for the moment usermode but some systems are shown to have the pihar bootkit also. (has its own partition).

 

Due to that fact zeroaccess keeps changing over the months and months,  All AV's are just having to keep, as do I in seeing the changes.

 

Quads

 

car825
Posts: 364
Topics: 71
Kudos: 9
Solutions: 3
Registered: ‎03-28-2009

Re: Symantec Please Speak Up About Rash of Trojans


techvisitor wrote:
car825 wrote:

dickevans wrote:

Hi,

Just a couple of comments. If the malware and virus developers wanted honest jobs I'm sure they would apply

Reinstalling from the installation disk is not 100%. Some things have been known to slip past and remain to bite again

Stay well and surf safe


What malware can survive a reinstall from a system image?  What about the malware giving people on the forum so much trouble now? 


Does anyone know the answer to this?  My system is clean, but I like knowing I can fix things with a full image copy restore.  How confident should I be in percentage terms that this is true.

 

 

I am mobile computer tech and have visited several customers with these infections.  I have in fact performed factory recovery on systems and had the virus maintain itself on the hard disk. A fully cleaned system was reinfected on reboot.  

 

I determined that the hard drive had to be nuked. We performed a full bit-by-bit erasure of all partition tables, boot sectors, and did a clean 1pass wipe.   

 

Having done that.... the computer was clean after a second re-install.  The downside is that we lost the manufacturers recovery partition and the supporting software and hardware the computer came with.  Thank MS for OEM COA labels on the side of machines! :)

 


Does this reinfection issue apply to the factory recovery on all computers or or just older ones? I have a new computer. The factory recovery removes all partitions, reformats the hard drive, reinstalls the operating system, and reinstalls all the hardware drivers and software. It also recreates the recovery partition.  Is this the same as nuking the hard drive?

twixt
Posts: 245
Topics: 6
Kudos: 118
Blog Posts: 0
Ideas: 0
Solutions: 13
Registered: ‎09-26-2011

Re: Symantec Please Speak Up About Rash of Trojans

[ Edited ]

car825 wrote:

techvisitor wrote:
car825 wrote:

dickevans wrote:

Hi,

Just a couple of comments. If the malware and virus developers wanted honest jobs I'm sure they would apply

Reinstalling from the installation disk is not 100%. Some things have been known to slip past and remain to bite again

Stay well and surf safe


What malware can survive a reinstall from a system image?  What about the malware giving people on the forum so much trouble now? 


Does anyone know the answer to this?  My system is clean, but I like knowing I can fix things with a full image copy restore.  How confident should I be in percentage terms that this is true.

 

 

I am mobile computer tech and have visited several customers with these infections.  I have in fact performed factory recovery on systems and had the virus maintain itself on the hard disk. A fully cleaned system was reinfected on reboot.  

 

I determined that the hard drive had to be nuked. We performed a full bit-by-bit erasure of all partition tables, boot sectors, and did a clean 1pass wipe.   

 

Having done that.... the computer was clean after a second re-install.  The downside is that we lost the manufacturers recovery partition and the supporting software and hardware the computer came with.  Thank MS for OEM COA labels on the side of machines! :)

 


Does this reinfection issue apply to the factory recovery on all computers or or just older ones? I have a new computer. The factory recovery removes all partitions, reformats the hard drive, reinstalls the operating system, and reinstalls all the hardware drivers and software. It also recreates the recovery partition.  Is this the same as nuking the hard drive?


 

Hi, car825.  A "Nuke & Pave" will destroy any rootkit.  All that is required is to rebuild the MBR and the Partition Table from scratch, such that the rootkit/bootkit's "fixit" partition is destroyed.  All modern laptops have this ability as part of their System Reinstall procedure.

 

Please note that techvisitor's procedure was overkill.  What should have happened is that machine should have had its recovery disks built when first purchased.  These CDs or DVDs could then have been used to rebuild the machine from scratch - including the machine's recovery partition, its custom driver information and the install utilities for those custom drivers.

 

 

There is a reason you are harassed when you first buy your machine to create those disks..........

 

And if you don't have them and are currently uninfected - it is still not too late to create them even now.

 

 

For those who did not make their Recovery Disks when they first purchased their laptop - and are now infected such that making a clean set of disks is not possible using the utility on the laptop itself -  the disks are available for purchase from the laptop manufacturer at nominal cost.

 

Consequently, no matter the circumstance, it is possible to recover from a rootkit/bootkit infection that has a "fixit" partition. 

 

However, what changes is the amount of time and money it takes to get the Recovery Disks into the hands of the person rebuilding the machine - which varies according to the amount of foresight the user possesses.

 

 

Note: The above is not a replacement for the work of Quads or another competent removalist.  It is simply prudent to have

           the ability to rebuild-from-scrach if all other procedures fail.

 

 

Hope this helps.