Available or not?

These recovery points, marked in red in this image, contain files that I would 
really like to get back. When I click on any of them and click "Recover" and 
then "Search", the files I want back appear in the results. When I select 
"recover to a folder on my desktop", a flag appears saying they cannot be 
recovered because they have been deleted. Why, then, are they listed as 
"Available"? Am I doing something wrong?