Can Norton Utilities fix "no sound" problems in Windows Vista?

Hello Norton Community people,

 

I am trying to fix a "no sound" problem for my mom on her PC that runs Vista... I'm aware of Vista's reputation.

 

I am an avid Mac user, but now I have had to become a reluctant PC IT guy.

 

I am on this Norton forum trying to find out if Norton Utilities can somehow fix the file corruption that is keeping the sound from working on this machine.

 

I am having big problems with no sound and no solution after a full month of troubleshooting on the phone and email with Microsoft technicians... they were even mounted to my desktop through TeamViewer many times... they have given up and sent me a Windows 7 installation disk, but I fear the problems that may bring.

 

I've tried MS "Fix It" for sound problems and countless other little and big solutions, including two failed "Vista In-place upgrades" that nearly brought down the whole system... but nothing has worked. I still have the little red X by my speakers icon in the task bar and it says, "No devices are installed.

 

 

I have run a successful Dell PSA diagnostic test built in to this computer that tests the sound board and the speakers... it plays the analog test song in both channels on both speakers perfectly... I heard it with my own ears... so I know the sound board and the speakers are working well.

 

But no amount of uninstalling, re-installing, deleting, or rolling back the Realtek sound driver, of any version from Dell, Realtek, the Windows update, or through the "Add Hardware" process will bring back the sound in this Vista software... the audio driver that was showing up as corrupt over and over, finally somehow installed completely after many failed installation attempts, and now shows up as okay in the device panel (with no yellow triangle corruption sign) but when I open the sound driver properties panel, it shows, "No drivers are installed for this device"!... and there is still no sound.

 

Does anyone know if Norton Utilities can somehow fix the file corruption that is keeping the sound from working on this machine?... I have browsed the instruction manual that I downloaded and I can not decipher if it is made to fix this kind of problem.

 

Thanks for any help,

 

numetro

 


 

Hi redk,


I'm not sure if you missed the part about the hardware and sound test that I did... see it in blue below...

 

"I have run a successful Dell PSA diagnostic test built in to this computer that tests the sound board and the speakers... it plays the analog test song in both channels on both speakers perfectly... I heard it with my own ears... so I know the sound board and the speakers are working well."


...so the hardware is not an issue. 


I updated the BIOS early on after the problem started to see if that was an issue, instructed by the Microsoft tech who spent so much time on the phone with me while mounted to my desktop... that did not fix it.


The In-place upgrade attempts, 2 of them, failed both times... the 2nd time it seemed to finish in the 4th stage and then bombed and went into a comma that took everything, including "fix my computer" from the Vista installation disk, start-up repairs, restore points, and then some... somehow it finally came back, but still with no sound. 


This computer has a sound card built in, if that is what you mean, but something in the Vista system software is keeping the motherboard from recognizing the sound board... that is what one of the MS techs was able to tell from a CBS.log that I created and sent to him.

 

This problem, I beleive, was caused by an Windows auto software update installation the day before the problem started... I lost the function of 3 different drivers the day after a CAPICOM update, and a failed multiple driver update that Vista did in the background while my mom was just reading filtered emails... no viruses or malware are on this machine, it has had several complete scans, one of them last night... it is clean.

 

By the time I discovered the Restore Point function, it was too many days beyond the day that the problem started to go back that far.

 

It lost the function of the NVIDIA Display Adapter driver, showing as corrupt and now is disabled to avoid start-up conflicts, so if my mom played games on this machine, it would be screwed up, but otherwise, it only affects the screensaver... she doens't play any games.

 

It has lost the sound function which is the Realtek HD Audio driver, which is what I've been trying to get fixed for my mom for one month today... all audio driver versions have been attempted, failed, succeeded, removed, un-installed, re-installed, and that still did nothing.

 

And the Plug and Play Software Device Enumerator driver is corrupt too... that is not affecting my mom's use... she just wants her sound back.


This is a Dell Inspiron 531 with a 2 GHZ processor, 1 GB of RAM and a "Nvidia integrated video (DirectX 9.0 Shader Model 3.9 Graphics Processing Unit)".  I don't know how to tell what kind of sound card it has in it... it is not published in the instruction manual or by entering the tag number on the Dell website... only the info above is what I can find.


One of the MS techs in India that  I was dealing with on the phone took pity on me and has sent a Windows 7 ULT full install disk, so I don't have to start all over with a Vista nightmare... so a clean install is what I'm looking at.


I was just trying to find out if there were any last ditch things I could do to save this OS, get the sound back, and not have to start from scratch, since the clean install would be with Windows 7, that is somewhat uncharted territory for anyone, let alone a Mac user.


Thanks for your reply,


numetro

I don't know of Vista having issues like you mention. When Vista first came out there was lack of drivers, etc. Your mother's PC had the drivers it needed to function. Since service pack 1 came out most people feel Vista works fine.

 

The computer came with Vista and the sound worked, right? So instead of installing WIndows 7, why not do a system restore to the factory image after all of your mother's pictures, music, email, etc are backed up.

 

How did you get support from MS? If it is a Dell computer. Normally Dell provides support.

 

Are you sure the speakers are the default device and not a headphone jack, optical output, etc.? Did you try plugging anything into the headphone jack to see if sound would come from there?

 

I also think you could stand to add more memory. 1GB is not really enough for Vista or Windows 7.

 

I wonder if someone could comment on the possibility of running SYSPREP. This deletes all drivers and prepares the PC to be booted on new hardware for the first time. WIndows would then reinstall the ones needed (you would have to make sure you had them available by downloading from Dell. This would be an extreme last resort effort that may fix your problem.

Hi redk,

 

I guess since I wrote so much information, it is easy to have missed some of what I wrote.

 

In my original post, and on my last post responding to you, I wrote:

 

"I have run a successful Dell PSA diagnostic test built in to this computer that tests the sound board and the speakers... it plays the analog test song in both channels on both speakers perfectly... I heard it with my own ears... so I know the sound board and the speakers are working well."

 

installing the driver from Dell was one of the first things I tried... Dell actually has 4 different versions of the Realtek HD audio driver available on their website for download... 2 of them have 2007 publish dates, and the 2 newest ones have 2008 publish dates... all are ALC888 HD drivers.

 

The Realtek website has several available with very new publish dates.

Uninstalling, removing, deleting, re-installing, disabling, and enabling this driver were the first things I tried and then the MS tech tried while mounted to my desktop... the driver kept coming back as corrupt.

Out of nowhere a few days ago, I tried uninstalling it again through Control Panel<Programs<Uninstall, then uninstalling it through the driver panel itself in Device Manager, then since it re-installs itself after restart, which always fails, I just installed it again with the newest Realtek ALC888 drive download before a restart, and it installed correctly, returned the "Sound video and game controllers" category that it was originally under, and showed up as okay, with no yellow corruption road sign. But the sound ability did not return and the device panel says, "No drivers are installed for this device." in the "Device Status" field in the "Driver" tab.


Microsoft is easy to get almost unlimited phone and email support from... it is Dell who keeps asking for your credit card number if you call them for advice.  Once you post a question on the Microsoft website, then it gives you 1-800 numbers to call for support.

 

They've even called me back unexpectedly a few times when a manager called to see how I was doing... all tolled I think they spent 15 hours or more with me on the phone and 8 or so hours mounted to my desktop through Teamviewer where the tech sees and controls my computer... and some 80 emails exchanged each way... all out of warranty.

 

In fact, just now while I was writing this to you, Alok, the main level 5 tech who has spent so much time with me, called to clear up a few details about clean installing Windows 7.

 

It is Microsoft software that is messing up this computer so it is Microsoft that tries, and they have tried very hard, to support their own software, in or out of warranty... I must grant them that... they even sent the Windows 7 ULT clean install disk, gratis.

 

At one point a manager told me that they had the Microsoft lab in Seattle looking into my case with Vista... that's like having bio lab scientists working on a broken lawnmower.

 

I'm not sure if I wrote about this before, but the Service Pack 1 auto upgrade installation failed months ago or sometime last year... I found a record of it's failed installation in the update history panel... so I don't think this computer will even install SP1. 

 

As far as the amount of RAM goes, 1 GB is what is required to run Windows 7, even Microsoft publishes that... and yesterday I discovered   http://mintywhite.com/books/   where there are free manuals for download.  The site and the manuals are all published by a guy named Rich Robinson, apparently quite some expert, and he wrote in one of his manuals that he has been able to run Windows 7 on a machine with only 512 MB of RAM, so I think I'm okay with 1 GB.

 

I know when I write a lot of information about this, moderators and techs tend to miss much of what I write, but if I leave anything out, then they write back asking about things that I left out so my post wouldn't be so long.

If you respond again, and I really do appreciate your responses and suggestions, please re-read my original posts and responses to go over everything that I have done, tried, failed with and been through.

This is the 4th forum that I am on, over the course of one 31 days, having spent 15 hours or more on the phone with MS techs, 8 or so hours with them mounted to my desktop, 80 or so emails sent, 80 or so received, and maybe 50 or so hours of total time trying to fix this.

I'm looking at re-formatting the hard drive and starting all over with everything backed up to the D drive, and clean installing Windows 7 fresh, which I'm trying to avoid for fear of unknown installation and operation issues that I've read about, and I still have level 5 and level 6 techs and moderators telling me to re-install the driver and check the speaker connection, like those are new ideas.

I appreciate your input, and I'm still looking for anything that will fix the sound on this computer before I wipe clean the hard drive and start a new odyssey with Windows 7... I would never re-install Vista with all of it's problems.

 

Thanks again,

 

Tracy

 


redk9258 wrote:

How about picking up an inexpensive sound card and install it?


This still sounds like a good idea. Simpler than installing Win7 and all the programs (if it works).

 

I still don't know why you give Vista such a bad rap. Most people that have problems are the ones trying to use devices that don't have drivers available (and a lot didn't when the OS was released). There are probably thousands of that same configuration Dell computer successfully running Vista with sound. It shouldn't take much of an effort to recover the factory Vista image that should have came with the computer, either on a disc or loaded another partition of the PC. Then run all of the updates and see what happens. Things happen to computers, both PC and Mac. If everyone that had that model Dell PC did not have sound, Dell would have to have a fix for it.

 

I know you said you had all of these different people working many hours trying to solve this sound problem. But they have not succeeded in fixing it.

 

I know you mentioned that you heard the sound when used that Dell test. I do not have a Dell, so I don't even know how it's run. Is it run from within Vista or under some special startup option that runs a stripped down OS. (My wife's HP has that feature like that.)

 

One more thing, yes you post a lot of information in one post. I really do think I have some sort of adult attention deficit disorder. That is - I lose concentration trying to read all of the way through.  So, sorry if I missed some things.

 

Good luck with whatever you do to get it working.

 

 

No worries redk,
I had a bit of a time finding the correct path to the "PSA Dell Diagnostics" menu myself.  It can be reached by pressing F12 when the BIOS sceen flashes for a few seconds before Windows starts to load... it takes you to one of those advanced boot menus that is a black screen with no mouse control... you know, where you navigate around with the arrow keys and by pressing Enter.
It loads from the Dell hardware or firmware, not through Windows, so you get to it before Windows ever loads... that's how it checks the internal hardware, including the sound board and peripherals, regardless of the state of the Windows OS.
The trick was, that the first webpage that I read this procedure on left out the step of first selecting the D utility drive to then see the diagnostic menu.
The PSA diagnostics have quite an extensive series of tests that you can choose to run... quick check of all hardware, full check of all hardware, and it will give error codes that can be identified if anything is wrong.
The nice part is something called "Symptom Tree" where you select a general problem from a list, like "no sound" and it tests the sound board and the speakers by playing a little song to see if you can hear the song... so I tried that and it plays a little song in each channel, left, then right, then in both channels, then a little panel pops up asking you if you heard the song, with two "Yes" or "No" choices... if you arrow to "Yes" and press enter, then it gives that test a pass and moves on to the next sound test.
It had an analog sound test, a surround sound test and several others, but this is just a simple system with analog speakers and I'm sure the simplest sound board... the speakers are just old Harman Kardon speakers that came with an older Dell tower that my mom got back in '99.
These HK195 speakers used to come with all the Dells that didn't have a built in speaker.
So the analog test ran and I heard the little song, and this confirms the soundboard and speakers are still working fine... it is somehow the Vista software that got corrupt and, according to one of the senior MS techs in India that had been helping me, he could see from a CBS.log information file that this computer can generate and save that I then sent to him on email, that the mother board is not recognizing the sound board.

This "no sound" problem started on 8/29, the next use session after 8/28 when Windows auto update did some driver update auto installations, plus a CAPICOM security update, and I think the attempted driver updates, including the audio driver and the video adaptor driver, both of which are now corrupt and unfixable, are what corrupted this Vista software beyond repair.
Below are the correct instructions on how I got to this diagnostic menu and test, and a mispublished mistake on the Dell website that left out one critical step about how to actually reach the diagnostic test menu...  remember sometimes links work from these forum pages and sometimes they do not, so just copy and paste a URL into a browser tab to get to that URL if clicking doesn't work... if you care to see them anyway.
The correct way to do it is in the Dell Inspiron 531 online HTML manual:   http://support.dell.com/support/topics/global.aspx/support/dsn/en/document?c=us&l=en&s=dhs&docid=300428&journalid=90978B514EF4FD23E040AC0A66E952F3
Starting the Dell Diagnostics From Your Hard Drive

The Dell Diagnostics is located on a hidden diagnostic utility partition on your hard drive.

  1. Ensure that the computer is connected to an electrical outlet that is known to be working properly.
  2. Turn on (or restart) your computer.
  3. When the DELL  logo appears, in the BIOS screen, press <F12> immediately. Select Utility Partition from the boot menu and press <Enter>. (this is the part - #3 - that is correct and the key to getting to the PSA Diagnostic utility)
  4. Then press any key to start the Dell Diagnostics from the diagnostics utility partition on your hard drive.
_________________________________________________________________________________________________ 
 
But the PSA Diagnostics instructions on the Dell webpage, below, leaves out the part, "Select Utility Partion from the boot menu and press <Enter>"
_______________________________________________________________
 
from the Dell website page "Technical Support for Inspiron Desktop 531":  http://support.dell.com/support/topics/global.aspx/support/dsn/en/document?c=us&l=en&s=dhs&docid=300428&journalid=90978B514EF4FD23E040AC0A66E952F3
 
 
Start the PSA Diagnostics
  1. Restart the system.


  2. At the Dell logo screen, press <F12>.

    At the One Time Boot menu, press the <Down> arrow key to highlight Diagnostics, then press <Enter> to begin PSA.  (this part is WRONG - it leaves out selecting the D utility drive to then see the diagnostics menu)

  3. Write down any error codes listed.


  4. Use the list provided in the next section to see what the error code means.

_________________________________________________________________________________________________
Since I'm a Mac guy, with computers that, even back 14 years ago with OS 7, OS 8, OS 9, and then into the newer UNIX platform OS Xs in 2000, are virtually virus proof, I've never experienced the software corruption and forced software updates that cause problems on Windows machines... I just get a little message panel that pops up once a week or so, sent from the Apple server that suggests some updates, and if I choose not to install them, it doens't demolish the operating system.
Heck, I never even used an anti-virus program on a Mac accept in art studios, digital pre-press centers and photo retouching departments to check incoming client files for viruses before loading them onto our machines.  At home with 3 Macs, I never have to worry about updating virus software and renewing it every year, and all the daily update patches that come in and force install on PCs... this machine of my mom's has failed the SP1 and SP2 updates that were supposed to be so critical... I found that in the update history log.
These are huge 434.5 MB patch installers that were supposed to download and install in the background, if the computer was turned on for 8 hours... but my mom just drives this computer to the store on Sundays and never has it running long enough to download and install these huge patches... and the novice user like her doesn't know about all of this stuff that I've been forced to learn in the last month... 31 days today of frustration trying to fix what should have been a simple problem.
The key would have been, if on 8/29, 8/30 or 8/31 when I was first in contact with MS techs on email and on the phone, if they then just would have told me to do a restore point back to the day before the problem started, it probably would have immediately fixed the sound problem. But by the time I figured out what restore point is on my own, it was too many days past the number of days that restore point can go back... that's the real pisser here.
But one the tech managers in the India support call center, Ashish, who called me a couple of times beyond the support calls, took pity on me and has provided me with a clean install version of Windows 7 ULT, gratis... so tomorrow, I venture into that territory... I've been scanning tech sights and finding downloadable PDF instruction manuals preparing for this installation and long re-set up process.
Here's a nifty tip...

Since there was no one there able to tell me where to get any e-book/PDF instruction manuals for Windows 7, I made a post on the MS Answers Forum and some nice guy replied with this link to a website that has 7 manuals to download, including 3 that are at least basic guides for Vista and Windows 7.


http://mintywhite.com/books/


Microsoft themselves should publish a section on their website like this, but that would make too much sense.

 

There are a bunch of other tech and how-to links on this site that I haven't yet explored... I never thought I would be roaming Microsoft tech sites, but here I am.

 

By looking at a few links on this website I can see the market that feeds the need that people have to fix broken Microsoft software.


It looks like someone named Rich Robinson publishes this... I guess he is quite the expert and web developer... what a great little site. You can find his personal section on his background, resumes, etc.


It is a little complicated to register to get the free e-book/PDF manuals... you click on a link for a book, then on the next page you enter your email address, then you receive an email confirming your registration, by which you then get their email newsletter each day that contains a new password to download the e-books. If the newsletter has already been sent out for that day, you click on a 2nd link in that email in order to receive another email with the password... then by clicking on a link in that 2nd email, you get to the page where you actually enter the password... then you can download the e-books... as easy as 1-2-3... 4-5-6-7-8 and 9.  

 

Hint, the password seems to be the same every day, or it has been for the last 2 days... it is "mintywhiteBooks"... very sneaky.


For a minute there I thought this website was some kind of a decoy because on the "subscribe/instructions" page, linked below, where you enter your email address, there are 2 jpeg images that look like password fields and links, but they are not... I'm not sure what these are for... but I figured it out and was able to download these nice manuals and help books. The one on Windows 7, for a "pocket guide" it is quite complete for installations and customizing.



So how is this for a long response... it'll really test your attention span... but I am the same way when I am reading... it is easy to drift off with other thoughts.

The pisser is, I got half way through writing this dissertation and this computer crashed again and started to go into another coma... I had to start all over again... the Windows 7 adventure starts tomorrow... wish I was getting paid for all this time, but it is for my mom, so what can I say.

Remember, it is better to have Attention Deficit Disorder than Deficit Attention Disorder.
Enjoy the PC world... I hate it now, but I've worked with PCs and XP that were okay... maybe Windows 7 will be better, provided I get it installed!

I see they are already talking about Windows 8 that will sense when you walk into the room and boot up with your user account and start playing your favorite music... I'm waiting to see what Apple's Mac OS XI will have in store too.
Enjoy,
numetro

It looks like the HTML correction code on these forum pages eliminated some of my line breaks and spaces... makes it harder to read when it's all globed together like that, but I think you can follow it.

 

Spater,

 

numetro

Brian K,

 

No new sound card needed... see the short story, or long story, that I wrote to "redk" below... Windows 7 is ready to be installed tomorrow and this machine only has a couple of extra programs and peripherals installed on it anyway... I already downloaded the couple of new drivers that it'll need for 7, if they're not already built in.

 

The HTML code corrector globed the lines together a little and deleted some of my line breaks and spaces, but it is still readable.

 

I've done my homework about a format disk and clean install, so we'll see what happens.

 

Thanks,

 

numetro

I still don't understand why you won't recover the factory image and run all of the updates. I would almost bet it will have sound.

Hi Numetro,


I suspect that the corruption of your Audio driver is due to some conflict with the Nvidia driver. Can you disable the Nvidia driver and the update the audio driver in order to check this?


If it is due to conflict, it may happen even after you update to Windows 7.


Yogesh

Hello Norton Community people,

 

I am trying to fix a "no sound" problem for my mom on her PC that runs Vista... I'm aware of Vista's reputation.

 

I am an avid Mac user, but now I have had to become a reluctant PC IT guy.

 

I am on this Norton forum trying to find out if Norton Utilities can somehow fix the file corruption that is keeping the sound from working on this machine.

 

I am having big problems with no sound and no solution after a full month of troubleshooting on the phone and email with Microsoft technicians... they were even mounted to my desktop through TeamViewer many times... they have given up and sent me a Windows 7 installation disk, but I fear the problems that may bring.

 

I've tried MS "Fix It" for sound problems and countless other little and big solutions, including two failed "Vista In-place upgrades" that nearly brought down the whole system... but nothing has worked. I still have the little red X by my speakers icon in the task bar and it says, "No devices are installed.

 

 

I have run a successful Dell PSA diagnostic test built in to this computer that tests the sound board and the speakers... it plays the analog test song in both channels on both speakers perfectly... I heard it with my own ears... so I know the sound board and the speakers are working well.

 

But no amount of uninstalling, re-installing, deleting, or rolling back the Realtek sound driver, of any version from Dell, Realtek, the Windows update, or through the "Add Hardware" process will bring back the sound in this Vista software... the audio driver that was showing up as corrupt over and over, finally somehow installed completely after many failed installation attempts, and now shows up as okay in the device panel (with no yellow triangle corruption sign) but when I open the sound driver properties panel, it shows, "No drivers are installed for this device"!... and there is still no sound.

 

Does anyone know if Norton Utilities can somehow fix the file corruption that is keeping the sound from working on this machine?... I have browsed the instruction manual that I downloaded and I can not decipher if it is made to fix this kind of problem.

 

Thanks for any help,

 

numetro