Identity safe not saving multiple logins

I recently had to reinstall (after using the Norton uninstall tool) my Norton Security Suite Version 5. I Checked the settings and the option for multiple logins is checked. I ran Live Update and restarted computer and ran again. This is happening in  both Firebox 9 and I.E. 9. Checked the extensions and have the most recent versions. It saves new logins but just won't recognize that I am trying to enter a new login for the same site, using a different user name and password. I can not find anywhere to enter this manually either. What am I missing? I am running Windows Vista.