I have the same problem. I think I did everything I was suposed to on 5/21 but as of today my site has this huge red X on it.
I don't even know how it got rated as a bad site. According to safeweb it has 63 FakeAV threaths. However if you clicked on any of the pages they went where they were supopsed to and were not hijacked..
But.. I signed up for safeweb. I verified ownership. I asked for a review. I even went so far as to completely redesign the site to make sure ther was NOTHING on it that could cause a bad rating.
And still, today, I have not heard from anyone nor has the bad rating been removed
HELP!!!
<<edit: subject edited for the moved post to reflect the issue>>